STAPLES Dexley Mesh Task Chair or STAPLES Mcallum Bonded Leather Swivel? Which STAPLES Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are deciding between the staples dexley mesh task chair vs mcallum bonded leather swivel. Both chairs support up to 275 lbs and feature black upholstery. They share a swivel-tilt mechanism for comfort. The main difference lies in the material and adjustability. The Dexley uses breathable mesh with multiple adjustment points. The Mcallum uses bonded leather with fixed arms. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize cooling airflow or a smooth, easy-to-clean surface for your workspace.
Key differences
| Aspect | Staples Dexley Mesh Task Chair | Staples Mcallum Bonded Leather Swivel Chair |
|---|---|---|
| Upholstery Material | Mesh | Bonded leather |
| Lumbar Support | Adjustable | Included (type not listed) |
| Headrest | Height and angle adjustable | Not listed |
| Armrests | Height adjustable | Fixed |
| Max Height | 50.8 inches | 47.8 inches |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Staples Dexley Mesh Task Chair if
- You need adjustable lumbar support to maintain proper posture during long work sessions.
- You prefer a breathable mesh seat that promotes airflow to keep you cool.
- You want to customize your headrest height and angle for better neck support.
Choose Staples Mcallum Bonded Leather Swivel Chair if
- You prefer a smooth, easy-to-clean bonded leather surface over mesh.
- You do not need adjustable armrests or a headrest.
- You want a chair with a simpler, fixed-arm design for a contemporary look.
Verdict: Choose the Dexley if you need extensive adjustability and breathable mesh for all-day comfort. Pick the Mcallum if you prefer the look and feel of bonded leather with fixed arms. Both chairs offer the same weight capacity and basic tilt functionality.
Dexley vs Mcallum Key Specs
Upholstery material
The Dexley uses a ventilated black mesh for the seat and back. This design promotes airflow to help keep you cool during long work sessions. The Mcallum features bonded leather upholstery. This material offers a smoother surface that is easy to clean with a damp cloth. Mesh provides breathability, while bonded leather gives a more traditional, polished look. You should choose mesh if you tend to run warm. Choose bonded leather if you prefer a sleek, easy-to-wipe surface that maintains a professional appearance in your office space.
Adjustability features
The Dexley offers extensive customization. You can adjust the seat height, armrest height, and headrest height and angle. It also includes a 3-position tilt lock and adjustable tilt tension. The Mcallum has fixed arms and a swivel-tilt mechanism. It does not list adjustable armrests, headrest, or tilt tension controls. The Dexley allows you to tailor the chair to your exact body dimensions and sitting preferences. The Mcallum provides basic comfort with limited adjustment options. If you need precise ergonomic tuning, the Dexley is the clear choice for personalized support.
Lumbar support
Both chairs include lumbar support to promote comfortable posture. The Dexley features an adjustable lumbar support system. This allows you to position the support exactly where your lower back needs it most. The Mcallum provides lumbar support as part of its cushioned design. However, the data does not specify if this support is adjustable. The Dexley’s adjustable feature lets you fine-tune the support level. The Mcallum offers standard support built into the chair structure. You should prefer the Dexley if you require customizable lower back alignment.
Overall dimensions
The Dexley measures 28.2 inches in width and 28.6 inches in depth. The Mcallum is slightly narrower at 28.1 inches wide but deeper at 31.3 inches. Both chairs have a similar width, fitting standard desk spaces. The Mcallum’s extra depth may provide more legroom or a larger seat surface. The Dexley is more compact in depth. Height ranges vary, with the Dexley reaching up to 50.8 inches and the Mcallum up to 47.6 inches. Consider your desk depth and height requirements when choosing between these two spatial footprints.
Weight capacity
Both the Staples Dexley and the Staples Mcallum support a maximum weight of 275 lbs. This capacity is sufficient for most users and aligns with standard office chair ratings. Neither chair offers a higher limit than the other. Both models are built to handle everyday office use within this weight range. The Dexley is rated for 5 to 10 hours of daily use. The Mcallum also supports this weight for typical professional environments. Since both share this identical specification, weight capacity does not differentiate the two options for you.
Which STAPLES chair fits your needs
You need full ergonomic adjustability
The Dexley lets you customize height, armrests, and headrest angle. It includes adjustable lumbar support and a tilt tension control. These features help you maintain a comfortable posture during long workdays. If you want a personalized setup that adapts to your body, this mesh chair offers the control you need.
You prefer a classic manager style
The Mcallum features bonded leather upholstery for a smooth, professional look. Its fixed arms provide stable support without complex mechanisms. This chair is easy to clean with a damp cloth. If you want a simple, durable office chair that complements a contemporary workspace, this leather model is a solid choice.
You work in a warm environment
The Dexley uses a ventilated mesh seat and back to promote airflow. This design helps keep you cool during extended work sessions. The Mcallum uses bonded leather, which can retain heat. If staying comfortable and cool is a priority, the breathable mesh material of the Dexley is the better option.
The products compared
Staples Dexley Mesh Task Chair
Best for: Users needing breathable mesh and headrest support
- Upholstery Material
- Mesh
- Lumbar Support
- Adjustable
- Armrest Adjustability
- Height adjustable
- Weight Capacity
- 275 lbs.
- Headrest Type
- Height and angle adjustable
- Safety Certifications
- ANSI/BIFMA
View on Amazon: Staples Dexley Mesh Task Chair Affiliate link
The STAPLES Dexley is a black mesh task chair with adjustable lumbar support. It features a ventilated seat and back to promote airflow during long sessions. You can customize height, armrests, and headrest angle. The chair supports up to 275 lbs and includes a 5-year warranty. It suits users who need breathable seating for daily office work.
Pros
- Breathable mesh seat and back for airflow
- Adjustable lumbar support for posture
- Height and angle adjustable headrest
- Supports up to 275 lbs
Cons
- Armrests only adjust in height
- Mesh cushion may feel firm to some
- Assembly required
Good fit if
- You prefer breathable mesh over leather
- You need adjustable headrest support
- You work in a warm environment
Skip if
- You want fully adjustable armrests
- You prefer plush cushioned seats
- You want a leather finish
Verdict: STAPLES Dexley Mesh Task Chair is a practical option for users who prioritize ventilation and adjustable headrest support over plush cushioning. It fits those who need a breathable seat for long hours at a desk.
Staples Mcallum Bonded Leather Swivel Chair
Best for: Users preferring traditional leather over mesh
- Upholstery Material
- bonded leather
- Lumbar Support
- integrated
- Armrest Adjustability
- fixed
- Weight Capacity
- 275 lb
- Color
- Black
- Dimensions
- 31.3 × 28.1 × 44.1 inches
View on Amazon: Staples Mcallum Bonded Leather Swivel Chair Affiliate link
The Staples Mcallum is a manager-style chair with a black bonded leather cushioned seat. It features fixed arms and a swivel-tilt mechanism for basic ergonomic adjustment. The frame supports up to 275 lbs and includes built-in lumbar support. Overall dimensions reach 47.6 inches in height. This model suits users who prefer a traditional office aesthetic over mesh ventilation.
Pros
- Bonded leather upholstery is easy to clean with a damp cloth
- Supports users up to 275 lbs
- Includes integrated lumbar support
- Swivel-tilt function allows for recline adjustment
Cons
- Armrests are fixed and do not adjust
- Upholstery is not breathable mesh material
- Seat height range is limited to 44.1-47.6 inches
Good fit if
- You want a chair with a professional, contemporary look
- You prefer easy-to-wipe bonded leather over fabric
- You need lumbar support in a standard office setting
Skip if
- You require adjustable armrests for custom positioning
- You need extensive height adjustment for a standing desk
- You prioritize maximum airflow for warm environments
Verdict: STAPLES Mcallum Bonded Leather Office Chair is a practical option for users seeking a traditional, easy-to-clean manager chair with fixed support features.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Staples Dexley Mesh Task Chair | Staples Mcallum Bonded Leather Swivel Chair |
|---|---|---|
| Upholstery Material | Mesh | bonded leather |
| Lumbar Support | Adjustable | integrated |
| Armrest Adjustability | Height adjustable | fixed |
| Weight Capacity | 275 lbs. | 275 lb |
| Headrest Type | Height and angle adjustable | not stated |
| Safety Certifications | ANSI/BIFMA | not stated |
| Features | Lumbar Support | not stated |
| Material | Mesh | Bonded Leather |
| Color | Black | Black |
| Dimensions | 28.6 × 28.2 × 45.3 inches | 31.3 × 28.1 × 44.1 inches |
| Weight | 37 pounds | not stated |
| Size | 1 Pack | 1 Pack |
| Model | Dexley | 51473 |
Frequently asked questions
Is the Dexley mesh chair good for hot climates?
Yes, the Dexley is designed for ventilation. Its black mesh material allows air to flow through the seat and back. This helps keep you cooler during long work sessions compared to solid upholstery. The Mcallum uses bonded leather, which does not offer the same breathability.
Does the Mcallum chair have an adjustable headrest?
The data does not list an adjustable headrest for the Mcallum. It is a manager-style chair with fixed support features. If you need headrest support, the Dexley is the better choice. It includes an adjustable headrest to help maintain proper neck alignment while you work at your desk.
Which chair is lighter to move around?
The Dexley is lighter. It weighs 37 pounds. The Mcallum does not list a specific weight in the provided data. However, the Dexley’s mesh construction and overall dimensions make it slightly more manageable to reposition if you need to change your workspace layout frequently.
Can I adjust the lumbar support on the Dexley?
Yes, the Dexley includes adjustable lumbar support. This feature helps you customize the lower back cushioning to fit your spine. The Mcallum does not mention adjustable lumbar support in its specifications. It offers fixed support features typical of a traditional office chair design.
What are the height dimensions for the Dexley?
The Dexley stands 45.3 inches tall. Its width is 28.2 inches and its length is 28.6 inches. The Mcallum is slightly shorter at 44.1 inches tall. It has a width of 28.1 inches and a length of 31.3 inches. These sizes help you plan your desk space.
Is bonded leather easier to clean than mesh?
Bonded leather is generally easier to wipe down. The Mcallum features this material for a smooth surface. Mesh surfaces can trap dust in the weave. The Dexley uses black mesh, which may require more frequent vacuuming to remove debris compared to the wipeable bonded leather of the Mcallum.
Do both chairs swivel and tilt?
Yes, both models feature a swivel-tilt mechanism. This allows you to rotate and recline for comfort. The Dexley adds tilt tension control for customized resistance. The Mcallum provides standard swivel and tilt functions. Both designs support movement while you work at your desk.